HomeBlogPhotography
Published Oct 23, 2024 ⦁ 13 min read
Photopea vs GIMP: Layer Management Comparison

Photopea vs GIMP: Layer Management Comparison

Looking for a free image editor? Here's a quick breakdown of GIMP and Photopea's layer management capabilities:

Feature GIMP Photopea
Type Desktop app Browser-based
Best for Large projects, offline work Quick edits, PSD files
Layer handling Slower with 10+ layers Better with multiple layers
Learning curve Steeper, custom interface Easier, Photoshop-like
Stability More stable, local saves Can crash in browser

Key differences at a glance:

Choose GIMP if you need:

Pick Photopea if you want:

Both tools are free and handle basic editing tasks well. GIMP works better for serious projects, while Photopea shines for quick edits and team collaboration.

Layer Interface Design

Here's how GIMP and Photopea handle their layer interfaces:

Feature GIMP Photopea
Window Style Pick between modular or single window Browser-based, fixed layout
Panel Location Move panels anywhere you want Right sidebar, two columns
Interface Type GIMP's own style Looks like Photoshop
Document Tabs Bottom of screen Top of screen

GIMP splits everything into three parts: your tools, your layers panel, and where you work on images. To find layers, just go to Windows > Dockable Dialogs > Layers.

Photopea keeps it simple: tools on the left, work area in the middle, layers on the right. That's it.

How the Panels Work

Here's what you'll find in each program's layer panel:

Section GIMP Photopea
Top Modes, opacity, locks Blend modes, opacity
Middle Layer thumbnails Layer list with previews
Bottom Layer controls Add/delete buttons
Extra Show/hide layer edges Fold panels away

GIMP gives you three ways to lock layers:

Making It Your Own

Each program lets you set up your workspace differently:

Setting GIMP Photopea
Previews Change thumbnail size Fixed size
Panel Spots Put them anywhere Stays in sidebar
Window Setup One window or many One browser window
Changes Move everything around Show/hide panels

Pro Move: Want bigger thumbnails in GIMP? Click the arrow in the top-right corner of the Layers Panel and pick "Preview Size". In Photopea, just fold panels you're not using to get more space.

Basic Layer Tools

Here's how to handle everyday layer tasks in GIMP and Photopea:

Task GIMP Photopea
Add Layer Shift+Ctrl+N Click "+" in layers panel
Delete Layer Press Delete Click trash or press Delete
Show/Hide Click eye icon Click eye icon
Select Multiple Ctrl+click layers Shift+click layers
Copy Layer Press Ctrl+D Right-click > Duplicate Layer
Create Group Layer > New Layer Group Click folder icon

Adding and Removing Layers

Both tools keep it simple:

Action GIMP Photopea
New Layer Shift+Ctrl+N Ctrl+Shift+N
Add from File File > Open as Layers Drop into browser
Delete Layer Delete key Delete key
Clear Contents Ctrl+A, Delete Ctrl+A, Delete

Show and Hide Layers

Quick visibility controls:

Action GIMP Photopea
One Layer Click eye icon Click eye icon
Multiple Layers Alt+click eye Alt+click eye
Show All Right-click > Show All Not available
Hide All Right-click > Hide All Not available

Selecting Layers

Pick your layers fast:

Action GIMP Photopea
One Layer Left click Left click
Multiple Ctrl+click Shift+click
Range Shift+click Shift+click ends
All Ctrl+A in panel Ctrl+A in panel

Copying Layers

Double your work:

Action GIMP Photopea
Same File Ctrl+D Ctrl+J
New File Drag to tab Drag to tab
Multiple Layer > Duplicate Not available

Layer Groups

Keep things tidy:

Action GIMP Photopea
New Group Layer > New Group Click folder
Add Layers Drag in Drag in
Open/Close Click arrow Click arrow
Move Drag name Drag name

"Photopea is great because we use it for a lot of graphic design work, anything that is customer facing." - Tanner K., Lead Sales & Marketing Analyst

Quick Tips:

Advanced Layer Features

Masks and Channels

GIMP and Photopea handle masks and channels differently. Here's what you need to know:

Feature GIMP Photopea
Layer Masks Requires alpha channel first Built-in mask support
Alpha Channels Built-in, affects file size Built-in
Group Masking Coming in future updates Available now
Mask Editing Paint tools, selections Paint tools, selections
File Impact Lower with masks vs alpha Standard file sizes

"The greatest advantage of an alpha channel over a layer mask is that the pixels of a layer can be stored using pre-multiplied alpha." - saulgoode, GIMP Chat Member

Adjustment Layers

The biggest difference? Photopea lets you edit your adjustments anytime. GIMP doesn't.

Type GIMP Photopea
Non-destructive Edits No built-in support Full support
Color Adjustments Apply directly to layer Separate adjustment layers
Re-editing Must redo changes Can modify any time
Smart Objects Not available Supported with Smart Filters
Workflow Duplicate layers + filters True adjustment layers

Layer Effects

Effect Type GIMP Photopea
Smart Filters Not available Yes, with masks
Filter Editing One-time application Re-editable
Masking Options Basic Advanced with Smart Objects
Plugin Support Extensive Limited

Blend Modes and Locks

Here's what each blend mode does:

Blend Mode Effect
Difference Subtracts values, shows absolute result
Addition Combines values, creates lighter output
Subtraction Opposite of Addition, white turns black
Darken Only Shows darker of two colors
Lighten Only Shows lighter of two colors

Want better results with blend modes? Here's what to do:

"Photopea is great because we use it for a lot of graphic design work, anything that is customer facing." - Tanner K., Lead Sales & Marketing Analyst

sbb-itb-507b909

Speed and Performance

GIMP and Photopea handle speed differently. Here's what you need to know:

Program Speed

GIMP launches fast because it runs right from your computer. But it's not all good news. Here's what actual users experience:

"While editing, I would do a brushstroke, then browse Facebook while waiting for the web program to catch up." - Chris Gampat, Author

Feature GIMP Photopea
Startup Time Fast local launch Browser-dependent load time
Layer Operations Slower with multiple layers Quick for basic tasks
CPU Usage High on multi-layer files Browser resource limits
Memory Management Local RAM usage Browser memory constraints
File Size Impact Better with large files Limited by browser cache

Working with Many Layers

Both programs hit speed bumps when handling lots of layers:

Issue GIMP Photopea
Layer Count Impact Slows after 10+ layers Handles multiple layers well
Preview Generation Slow initial rendering Quick layer previews
Tool Response Lags with visible layers Internet speed dependent
Background Tasks Heavy CPU load Limited by browser
Crash Risk Low, local saves Higher, no autosave

Want better speed? Here's what works:

In GIMP:

In Photopea:

Bottom line: GIMP won't crash much but gets slow with layers. Photopea handles layers better but depends on your internet and browser power.

Common Uses

Here's how GIMP and Photopea handle layers for different tasks:

Photo Editing

Task GIMP Photopea
Background Removal Manual masking - takes more time Fast selection tools
Color Adjustments Need separate layers Direct adjustment layers
Text Overlays Basic text options More text effects
Multiple Images Slows down after 10 layers Handles many layers
File Format Support Basic PSD support Works with all PSD files

GIMP works fine for basic photo edits. But Photopea makes it easier with better tools and PSD support.

Digital Art

Feature GIMP Photopea
Brush Layers Make your own brushes Standard brush set
Layer Groups Simple groups More group options
Canvas Size No size limits Limited by browser
Layer Effects Manual work needed Ready-to-use effects
Drawing Tools Basic tools Better path options

Artists pick GIMP for custom brushes. Photopea wins for quick effects and path tools.

Design Work

Design Task GIMP Photopea
Logo Design Good with masks Works with smart objects
Web Graphics Manual export Built-in export tools
Print Files No CMYK support Better for print work
UI Elements Basic shapes Vector shapes included
Mockups Few templates Many PSD templates

Want to work better with layers? Here's what to do:

Bottom line: GIMP works best for photo edits and custom work. Pick Photopea if you need PSD files or design tools that match Photoshop.

Program Comparison

Let's break down GIMP vs Photopea to help you pick the right tool.

Core Features

Feature GIMP Photopea
Cost Free, no ads Free with ads, $5/month premium
Installation Local software Browser-based, no install
Plugins 1000+ available Limited options
File Support Basic PSD support Full PSD compatibility
Resource Use Runs from flash drive Browser memory dependent
Platform Windows, Mac, Linux Any device with browser

Pain Points

Issue GIMP Photopea
Interface Cluttered menus Browser limitations
Layer Tools No adjustment layers Lags with many layers
Performance Slow with large files Can crash in browser
Export Options Limited formats Better format support
Learning Curve Takes time to learn Easier for PS users
CMYK Support Not available Limited support

When to Use Each Tool

Task Better Choice Why
Quick Edits Photopea No installation needed
Custom Brushes GIMP More customization options
Large Projects GIMP More stable performance
Team Projects Photopea Easy file sharing
PSD Work Photopea Better compatibility
Plugin Tasks GIMP Large plugin library

"Photopea is great because we use it for a lot of graphic design work, anything that is customer facing." - Tanner K., Lead Sales & Marketing Analyst

Here's what you need to know:

GIMP is your go-to for:

Photopea shines when you need:

Both tools handle basic editing just fine. Pick GIMP if you want a stable, long-term solution. Go with Photopea if you need something fast and web-based.

Which One to Choose

Let's break down GIMP and Photopea to help you pick the right tool.

For Pro Users

GIMP wins for serious work. Here's why: It runs on your computer (not in a browser), handles big projects better, and lets you add 1000+ plugins.

Pro Feature GIMP Photopea
Plugin Support 1000+ plugins Limited options
Resource Usage Local processing Browser-dependent
Large Files Better handling Can lag or crash
Customization Full control Basic settings

For Beginners

Want to jump right in? Photopea might be your best bet. It looks and feels like Photoshop, so you'll feel at home if you've used that before.

Beginner Feature GIMP Photopea
Learning Curve 3.9/5 ease of use 4.5/5 ease of use
Setup Time Installation needed Instant browser access
Interface Complex menus Simple, familiar layout
File Support Basic PSD support Full PSD compatibility

Tips for Daily Use

Here's what works best with each tool:

GIMP:

Photopea:

"GIMP is the most feature rich free image editing tool." - Slant Community

Need a quick answer? Here's your cheat sheet:

If You Need Choose
No installation Photopea
Heavy editing GIMP
PSD work Photopea
Plugin options GIMP
Quick edits Photopea
Offline access GIMP

FAQs

How do you use layers in Photopea?

Photopea

Working with layers in Photopea is pretty straightforward. Here's what you need to know:

The basics are simple: drag layers up and down in the Layers panel to change their order. Want to move multiple layers? Just hold Shift and click the ones you want.

Here's a breakdown of common layer actions:

Action How to Do It
Move Layers Drag and drop in Layers panel
Select Multiple Hold Shift + click layers
Create Groups Drag layers into folders
Nest Groups Move folders into other folders
Change Order Drag up (front) or down (back)

Think of layers like a stack of transparent sheets. The top layer shows up first, and everything below it shows through the transparent parts.

The Layers panel makes it easy to spot what you're looking for:

Layer Position What You See
Top of Panel Front of Image
Middle of Panel Middle Layers
Bottom of Panel Background

Each layer comes with a tiny preview image next to it - super helpful when you're juggling lots of elements in your design.

Want to stay organized? Group related layers into folders. You can even put folders inside other folders for complex projects.

DesignPhotoEditingSoftware

Related posts